Colonel William A. Phillips

Add links

The 1855 Kansas Territory elections were a series of pivotal moments in the "Bleeding Kansas" conflict between pro-slavery individuals and "Free-Staters" in Kansas Territory. The initial elections for territorial legislature, held on March 30, 1855, were marred by widespread voter fraud, intimidation, and violence, as pro-slavery forces from neighboring Missouri crossed the border to cast ballots and suppress anti-slavery voters. In response, Kansas Territorial governor, Andrew H. Reeder, ordered new elections to be held on May 22 in certain districts. But even after the corrective elections, pro-slavery candidates still managed to win a majority of seats in the territorial legislature. When the legislature convened in July, it promptly ejected all the Free-State candidates who had won seats in the May elections. This act led to many Kansans lambasting the body as the "Bogus Legislature."

In October 1855, elections were held for a Congressional delegate to represent Kansas Territory in the House of Representatives. Pro-slavers held their elections on October 1 and choose John Wilkins Whitfield, whereas Free-Staters held theirs on October 8 and selected Reeder. Whitfield was initially seated as the lawful delegate, but after Reeder petitioned the House, the seat was vacated on August 1, 1856 and a new election was ordered.

Territorial legislature election results

Territorial Council results

Summary of the 1855 Kansas Territory Council election results
Faction March 30 elections May 22 elections Total seats
Pro-slavery 10 0 10
Free-State 1 2 3[i]
Source: Andreas, Alfred T. (1883). History of the State of Kansas. Chicago: A. T. Andreas. pp. 95–101.

March 30 election results

Council District 1[2][3]
Faction Candidates Votes %
Pro-slavery Thomas Johnson
Edward Chapman 		900[ii] 79.08
Free-State Joel K. Goodwin
Samuel Newitt Wood 		273 23.08
– "Scattering" votes 10 0.84
Total votes cast 1,183
Illegally cast[3] 827 69.91
Pro-slavery gain[4]
Council District 2[3]
Faction Candidate Votes %
Pro-slavery A. McDonald 318 96.36
Free-State J. A. Wakefield 12 3.64
Total votes cast 330
Illegally cast[3] 316 95.76
Results abrogated; new election ordered[5]
Council District 3[3]
Faction Candidate Votes %
Pro-slavery H. S. Strickler 598 92.71
Free-State William F. Johnson 23 3.56
Free-State — Rice 17 2.64
Free-State A. McDonald 4 0.62
– "Scattering" votes 3 0.46
Total votes cast 645[iii]
Illegally cast[3] 547 84.81
Results abrogated; new election ordered[5]
Council District 4[3]
Faction Candidates Votes %
Pro-slavery A. M. Coffee
David Lykins 		680 79.53
Free-State M. G. Morris
James P. Fox 		158 18.47
– "Scattering" votes 17 1.99
Total votes cast 855
Illegally cast[3] 630 73.68
Pro-slavery gain[4]
Council District 5[3]
Faction Candidate Votes %
Pro-slavery William Barbee 343 100
Total votes cast 343
Illegally cast[3] 243 70.84
Pro-slavery gain[4]
Council District 6[2][3]
Faction Candidate Votes %
Free-State Martin F. Conway 139[iv] 66.51
Pro-slavery John Donaldson 68[iv] 32.54
– "Scattering" votes 2 0.96
Total votes cast (Election Districts 9-12) 540[v]
Total votes cast (Election Districts 9-10, 12) 209[vi]
Illegally cast (Election Districts 9-12) 345[vii] 63.89
Illegally cast (Election Districts 9-10, 12) 21[viii] 10.04
Free-State gain[4]
Council District 7[3]
Faction Candidate Votes %
Pro-slavery John W. Foreman 478 100
Total votes cast 478
Illegally cast[3] 207 43.30
Pro-slavery gain[4]
Council District 8[3]
Faction Candidate Votes %
Pro-slavery W. P. Richardson 234 77.48
Free-State John W. Whitehead 68 22.52
Total votes cast 302
Illegally cast[3] 166 55.00
Pro-slavery gain[4]
Council District 9[3]
Faction Candidate Votes %
Pro-slavery D. A. M. Grover 411 99.76
– "Scattering" votes 1 0.24
Total votes cast 412
Illegally cast[3] 332 80.58
Pro-slavery gain[4]
Council District 10[2][3]
Faction Candidates Votes %
Pro-slavery R. R. Rees
J. J. Eastin 		1,129 94.48
Free-State B. H. Twombly
A. J. Whitney 		66[ix] 5.52
Total votes cast 1,195[x]
Illegally cast[3] 1,044[xi] 86.57
Pro-slavery gain[4]

May 22 election results

Council District 2[4]
Faction Candidate Votes %
Free-State J. A. Wakefield 127 100
Total votes cast 127
Free-State gain[4]
Council District 3[4]
Faction Candidate Votes %
Free-State Jesse D. Wood 214 86.64
Free-State C. H. Washington 33 13.36
– "Scattering" votes 14 0.84
Total votes cast 247
Free-State gain[4]

Territorial House results

Summary of the 1855 Kansas Territory House of Representatives election results
Faction March 30 elections May 22 elections Total seats
Pro-slavery 15 3 18
Free-State 2 6 8[xii]
Source: Andreas, Alfred T. (1883). History of the State of Kansas. Chicago: A. T. Andreas. pp. 95–101.

March 30 election results

House District 1[2][8]
Faction Candidate Votes %
Pro-slavery A. S. Johnson 120 84.51
Free-State A. F. Powell 19 13.38
– "Scattering" votes 3 2.11
Total votes cast 142[xiii]
Illegally cast[8] 65[xiv] 45.77
Pro-slavery gain[4]
House District 2[2][8]
Faction Candidates Votes %
Pro-slavery Jatues Whitlock
J. M. Banks
A. B. Wade 		781 74.81
Free-State John Hutchison
E. D. Ladd
P. P. Fowler 		253 24.23
– "Scattering" votes 10 0.96
Total votes cast 1,044[xv]
Illegally cast[8] 802[xvi] 76.82
Results abrogated; new election ordered[5]
House District 3[2][8]
Faction Candidates Votes %
Pro-slavery G. W. Ward
O. H. Brown 		318 93.26
Free-State Isaac Davis
E. G. Macy 		12 3.52
– "Scattering" votes 11 3.23
Total votes cast 341
Illegally cast[8] 316 31.09
Results abrogated; new election ordered[5]
House District 4[2][8]
Faction Candidate Votes %
Pro-slavery D. L. Croysdale 366 98.65
Free-State Cyrus K. Holliday 4 1.08
– "Scattering" votes 1 0.27
Total votes cast 371[xvii]
Illegally cast[8] 338[xviii] 91.11
Results abrogated; new election ordered[5]
House District 5[2][8]
Faction Candidates Votes %
Free-State A. J. Baker 25[xix] 64.10
Pro-slavery M. W. McGee 12[xix] 30.77
Free-State H. Rice 0[xix] 0
– "Scattering" votes 2 5.13
Total votes cast (Election Districts 7–8) 273[xx]
Total votes cast (Election District 8 only) 39[xxi]
Illegally cast (Election Districts 7–8)[8] 209[xxii] 76.56
Free-State gain[4]
House District 6[2][8]
Faction Candidates Votes %
Pro-slavery Joseph C. Anderson
S. A. Williams 		315 90.0
Free-State John Hamilton
William Margraves 		35 10.0
Total votes cast 350
Illegally cast[8] 250 71.43
Pro-slavery gain[4]
House District 7[2][8]
Faction Candidates Votes %
Pro-slavery W. A. Haskall
A. Wilkinson
H. Younger
Samuel Scott 		684 80.19
Free-State John Serpell
Adam Pore
S. H. Houser
William Jennings 		152 17.82
– "Scattering" votes 17 1.99
Total votes cast 853[xxiii]
Illegally cast[8] 630[xxiv]
Pro-slavery gain[4]
House District 8[2][8]
Faction Candidate Votes %
Free-State S. D. Houston 120 71.86
Pro-slavery Russell Garrett 41 24.55
– "Scattering" votes 6 3.59
Total votes cast 167
Illegally cast[8] 10[xxv] 5.99
Free-State gain[4]
House District 9[2][8]
Faction Candidate Votes %
Pro-slavery J. Marshall 344 91.98
Free-State H. McCartney 26 6.95
– "Scattering" votes 4 1.07
Total votes cast 374[xxvi]
Illegally cast[8] 321 85.83
Pro-slavery gain[4]
House District 10[2][8]
Faction Candidate Votes %
Pro-slavery William H. Tibbs 237 98.75
Free-State C. Hard 3 1.25
Total votes cast 240[xxvii]
Illegally cast[8] 230[xxviii] 95.83
Pro-slavery gain[4]
House District 11[2][xxix]
Faction Candidates Votes %
Pro-slavery J. H. Stringfellow
R. L. Kirk 		420 87.5
Free-State G. A. Cutler
John Landis 		54 11.25
– "Scattering" votes 6 1.25
Total votes cast 480
Illegally cast[2] – –
Pro-slavery gain[4]
House District 12[2][xxix]
Faction Candidates Votes %
Pro-slavery J. P. Blair
T. W. Watterson 		258 99.23
Free-State Joel Ryan
John Fee 		2 0.77
Total votes cast 260
Illegally cast[2] – –
Pro-slavery gain[4]
House District 13[2][xxix]
Faction Candidates Votes %
Pro-slavery H. B. C. Harris
J. Weddell 		412 100
Total votes cast 412
Illegally cast[2] – –
Pro-slavery gain[4]
House District 14[2][xxix]
Faction Candidates Votes %
Pro-slavery H. B. McMeeken
Archy Payne
W. G. Mathias 		897 93.83
Free-State Felix G. Braden
Samuel France
F. Browning 		59 6.17
Total votes cast 956
Illegally cast[2][xxix] 906 94.77
Results abrogated; new election ordered[5]

May 22 election results

House District 2[4]
Faction Candidates Votes %
Free-State John Hutchison
Erastus. D. Ladd
Philip P. Fowler 		288 94.12
– "Scattering" votes 18 5.88
Total votes cast 306
Free-State gain[4]
House District 3[4]
Faction Candidates Votes %
Free-State Augustus Wattles
William Jessee 		127 100
Total votes cast 127
Free-State gain[4]
House District 4[4]
Faction Candidate Votes %
Free-State Cyrus K. Holliday 148 99.33
– "Scattering" votes 1 0.67
Total votes cast 149
Free-State gain[4]
House District 14[4]
Faction Candidates Votes %
Pro-slavery H. B. McMeeken
Archy Payne
W. G. Mathias 		700 97.90
– "Scattering" votes 15 2.10
Total votes cast 715
Pro-slavery gain[4]

Outcome

After the March 30, 1855 elections were marred by voting fraud, Kansas Territorial governor Andrew Horatio Reeder called for new elections in select districts.

Initial returns suggested that voters had chosen 13 pro-slavery councilmen and 25 pro-slavery representatives. Free-state settlers immediately cried foul, citing demonstrable voting irregularities, and so the governor of Kansas Territory, Andrew Horatio Reeder, scrutinized the results: On April 6, 1855, he declared Martin F. Conway the winner of the sixth district, and he also called for new elections for Council Districts 2–3 and House Districts 2–4, and 14. These elections, held on May 22, were all won by Free-Staters with the exception of the House District 14 race. After the governor granted election certificates, the Council was consequently left with 10 pro-slavery and 3 Free-state members, whereas the House was left with 18 pro-slavery and 8 Free-state members.[9] However, when the territorial legislature met for the first time on July 2, 1855, it expelled all the Free-state men who had been elected in May. The remaining Free-State representative, S. D. Houston, would resign in protest on July 23.[10][xxx] The legislature's decision to eject most of its Free-State members led to many in Kansas denouncing it as the "Bogus Legislature".[11]

On March 19, 1856, the US House of Representatives tasked a special committee, comprising William A. Howard (O-Michigan), John Sherman (O-Ohio), and Mordecai Oliver (O-Missouri),[12] with investigating "the troubles in the Territory of Kansas."[13] Their report, "Report of the Special Committee Appointed to Investigate the Troubles in Kansas", was published later in 1856. In this document, the committee's majority contended that "each election in the Territory, held under the organic or alleged Territorial law, has been carried by organized invasion from the State of Missouri by which the people of the Territory have been prevented from exercising the rights secured to them by the organic law."[14] The majority also argued that, in their opinion, "the alleged Territorial legislature was an illegally constituted body, and had no power to pass valid laws, and their enactments are therefore null and void."[14] Finally, the committee majority argued that "in the present condition of the Territory a fair election cannot be held without a new census, a stringent and well-guarded election law, the selection of impartial judges, and the presence of United States troops at every place of election."[14]

Congressional delegate election results

John Wilkins Whitfield was elected as Kansas Territory's congressional delegate in the October 1, 1855 election. The legality of that election would later be questioned by the United States House of Representatives.

October 1 (Pro-Slavery) elections

Congressional delegate (October 1, 1855)[15][16]
Party Candidate Votes %
Pro-slavery Democrat[17] John Wilkins Whitfield 2,721 99.38
– "Scattering" votes 17 0.62
Total votes cast 2,738
Pro-Slavery Democrat selected as delegate[15][16]

October 9 (Free-State) elections

Congressional delegate (October 9, 1855)[15][16]
Party Candidate Votes %
Free-State Democrat[18] Andrew H. Reeder 2,849 100
Total votes cast 2,849
Free-State Democrat selected as delegate[15][16]

Outcome

Following the two elections, Whitfield (the incumbent who had last been elected in 1854)[19] presented his election credentials to the 34th United States Congress and was subsequently seated as the delegate from Kansas Territory. Following this, Reeder petitioned Congress to eject Whitfield and install himself as the valid delegate.[20][21] In response to this conflict, the House of Representatives issued the "Report of the Special Committee Appointed to Investigate the Troubles in Kansas", penned by a special committee tasked with analyzing the territory's elections. In this document, the majority agreed that "the election under which the sitting delegate, John Whitfield, holds his seat, was not held in pursuance of any valid law and that it should be regarded only as the expression of the voice of those resident citizens who voted for him."[14] However, the committee majority also argued that "the election, under which the contesting delegate, Andrew H. Reeder, claims his seat, was not held in pursuance of law, and that it should be regarded only as the expression of the resident citizens who voted for him."[14]

As a result, the House voted on August 1, 1856 to vacate Whitfield's seat and hold a new election.[20][21] In the subsequent election, Whitfield would again be elected, and Reeder would again contest the results.[22] In 1857, the Committee on Elections once again recommended that Whitfield be declared not entitled to the seat because non-residents had voted and because many Kansans had been disenfranchised in the 1856 election, but the House narrowly decided to table the resolution. Whitfield served provisionally from December 9, 1856, to March 3, 1857.[23]

Notes

  1. ^ a b Martin F. Conway (a Free-State councilman who was elected in March 1855), never took his seat. In July 1855, Jesse D. Wood and John A. Wakefield (who had been elected in the corrective May election) were unseated by the pro-slavery majority and their positions were filled by Andrew McDonald and Hiram J. Strickler.[1]
  2. ^ While this number is present in Andreas (1883),[2] it is not explicitly given in the House's report. It can be derived by adding the total votes for Johnson/Chapman from the first (780 votes), fourth (78 votes), and seventeenth (42 votes) election districts.[3]
  3. ^ This is the total number of votes cast in the third (374 votes), seventh (234 votes), and eighth (37 votes) election districts. Andreas (1883) correctly gives the total as 645[2] whereas the total is miscalculated as 642 in the House's report.[3]
  4. ^ a b According to initial returns, Donaldson received 395 and Conway received 142.[2] However, Gov. Reeder later disqualified all the results from the 11th Election District because the vote there had been held viva voce instead of by ballot (as required by law). The rejection of these results cost Donaldson 328 votes and Conway 3, swinging the election in Conway's favor.[6]
  5. ^ This is the total number of votes cast in the ninth (75 votes), tenth (92 votes), eleventh (331 votes), and twelfth (42 votes) election districts. Andreas (1883) correctly gives the total as 540,[2] whereas the total is miscalculated as 538 in the House's report.[3]
  6. ^ This is the total number of votes cast in the ninth (75 votes), tenth (92 votes), and twelfth (42 votes) election districts.[2][3]
  7. ^ This is the total number of illegal votes cast in the ninth, tenth, eleventh, and twelfth election districts.[2][3]
  8. ^ This is the total number of illegal votes cast in only the ninth, tenth, and twelfth election districts.[3]
  9. ^ This is the total number of votes cast in the thirteenth (6 votes) and sixteenth (60 votes) election districts for both Twombly and Whitney. Andreas (1883) correctly gives the total as 66[2] whereas the total is miscalculated as 166 in the House's report.[3]
  10. ^ This is the total number of votes cast for Rees/Eastin in the thirteenth (233 votes) and sixteenth (896 votes) election districts, combined with the total number of votes cast for Twombly/Whitney in the thirteenth (6 votes) and sixteenth (60 votes) election districts.[2] Andreas (1883) correctly gives the total as 1,195,[2] whereas the total is miscalculated as 1,206 in the House's report.[3]
  11. ^ This is the total number of illegal votes cast in the thirteenth (230 votes) and sixteenth (814) election districts.[7] Andreas (1883) erroneously gives the total as 1,033.[2]
  12. ^ a b In July 1855, John Hutchison, Erastus. D. Ladd, Philip P. Fowler, Augustus Wattles, William Jessee, and Cyrus K. Holliday (Free-Staters who had been elected in the corrective May election), as well as A. J. Baker (a Free-Stater who had been elected in the March elections by a technicality) were unseated by the pro-slavery majority and their positions were filled by James Whitlock, John M. Banks, A. B. Wade, G. W. Ward, O. H. Brown, D. L. Croysdale, and M. W. McGee (all of whom were pro-slavery in alignment). The remaining Free-State representative, S. D. Houston, would resign in protest on July 23.[1]
  13. ^ This is the total number of votes for Johnson (120 votes), Powell (19 votes), and any scattering votes (3).[2][8] Andreas (1883) correctly gives the total as 142,[2] whereas the total is miscalculated as 139 in the House's report.[8]
  14. ^ Andreas (1883) has the number as 68.[2]
  15. ^ This is the total number of votes for Whitlock/Banks/Wade (781 votes), Hutchison/Ladd/Fowler (253 votes), and any scattering votes (10).[2][8] Andreas (1883) correctly gives the total as 1,044,[2] whereas the total is miscalculated as 1,034 in the House's report.[8]
  16. ^ Andreas (1883) has the number as 812.[2]
  17. ^ This is the total number of votes for Croysdale (366 votes), Holliday (4 votes), and any scattering votes (1).[2][8] Andreas (1883) correctly gives the total as 371,[2] whereas the total is miscalculated as 370 in the House's report.[8]
  18. ^ Andreas (1883) has the number as 308.[2]
  19. ^ a b c According to initial returns, McGee received 222 votes (210 of which were from seventh election district),[8] Baker received 26 (1 of which was in the seventh election district), and H. Rice received 23 (all from the seventh election district).[2][8] However, Gov. Reeder later disqualified all the results from the 7th Election District because the judges overseeing the vote had not been sworn in. The rejection of these results cost McGee 210 votes, Baker 1 vote, and Rice all of his votes. This swung the election in Baker's favor.[6]
  20. ^ This number is the sum of the votes cast in the seventh (234 votes) and eighth (37 votes) election districts[2][8] plus two scattering votes reported by Andreas.[2]
  21. ^ This number is the sum of the votes cast in the eighth (37 votes) election districts[2][8] plus two scattering votes reported by Andreas.[2]
  22. ^ Andreas (1883) has the number as 211.[2]
  23. ^ This is the total number of votes for Haskall et al. (684 votes), Serpell et al. (152 votes), and 17 scattering votes.[2][8] Andreas (1883) correctly gives the total as 853,[2] whereas the total is miscalculated as 855 in the House's report.[8]
  24. ^ Andreas (1883) has the number as 629.[2]
  25. ^ Andreas (1883) has the number as 11.[2]
  26. ^ This is the total number of votes for Marshall (344 votes), McCartney (26 votes), and 4 scattering votes.[2][8] Andreas (1883) correctly gives the total as 374,[2] whereas the total is miscalculated as 370 in the House's report.[8]
  27. ^ This is the total number of votes for Tibbs (237 votes) and Hard (3 votes).[2][8] Andreas (1883) correctly gives the total as 240,[2] whereas the total is miscalculated as 242 in the House's report.[8]
  28. ^ Andreas (1883) has the number as 228.[2]
  29. ^ a b c d e Unless otherwise noted, these results are based exclusively on Andreas (1883), due to a typesetting error rendering page 33 of the House's report unworkable.[8]
  30. ^ The Free-State councilman M. F. Conway never took his seat, officially resigning on July 3, 1855.[10]

References

  1. ^ a b Andreas (1883), pp. 102–103.
  2. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z aa ab ac ad ae af ag ah ai aj ak al am an ao ap aq ar as at au av aw ax ay az ba bb bc Andreas (1883), p. 96.
  3. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z aa Howard et al. (1856), p. 31.
  4. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z aa ab ac ad Andreas (1883), p. 101.
  5. ^ a b c d e f Andreas (1883), pp. 97–98.
  6. ^ a b Andreas (1883), pp. 96–98.
  7. ^ Howard et al. (1856), pp. 30–31.
  8. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z aa ab ac ad ae af ag ah ai aj ak Howard et al. (1856), p. 32.
  9. ^ Andreas (1883), pp. 97–101.
  10. ^ a b Andreas (1883), 102–103.
  11. ^ Roe, Jason. "The Contested Election of 1855". Civil War on the Western Border. Retrieved November 14, 2023.
  12. ^ Kansas State Historical Society (1881), pp. 146–147.
  13. ^ Howard et al. (1856), p. 1.
  14. ^ a b c d e Howard et al. (1856), p. 67.
  15. ^ a b c d Andreas (1883), p. 111.
  16. ^ a b c d Admire (1891), p. 193.
  17. ^ Schwab, Scott (June 28, 2018). "Election Security Shouldn't Hinge on Personalities". Kansas City Star. Retrieved November 15, 2023.
  18. ^ Socolofsky (2021), p. 34.
  19. ^ House of Representatives Historian. "Whitfield, John Wilkins: 1818 – 1879". Biographical Dictionary of the United States Congress. Retrieved November 15, 2023.
  20. ^ a b United States Congress (1950), p. 255.
  21. ^ a b Bartlett (1865), pp. 185–203.
  22. ^ "KS Territorial Delegate – Special Election". Our Campaigns. Retrieved November 15, 2023.
  23. ^ Hinds (1907), pp. 1076–1078.

Bibliography

source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1855_Kansas_Territory_elections